# How to Compare Your Florida Home Insurance Renewal, Line by Line

Source page: https://insuranceoutreach.com/renewal/compare-home-insurance-renewal/
Topic: Renewals and Citizens (Florida)
Last updated: 2026-11-17
Publisher: Insurance Outreach (https://insuranceoutreach.com/)

## Short answer

Lay last year's declarations page next to the renewal. Check each coverage limit, turn both deductibles into dollars, and look for changes to roof terms, water limits and discounts. Then get new quotes built on the same limits and deductibles, so you compare prices for the same coverage. Florida insurers must send the renewal premium at least 45 days before it's due.

## Key takeaways

- Florida law requires at least 45 days' written notice of your renewal premium.
- Turn every percentage deductible into dollars before you compare anything.
- A cheaper quote with a bigger hurricane deductible can cost you thousands in a storm year.
- Ask for quotes on the same Coverage A, deductibles and roof terms as your renewal.

Most people open the renewal, look at the total, and either sigh or shrug. The total is the last number you should look at. A renewal can cost the same as last year and still cover you for less, or cost more because your home is now insured for more.

The fix is a side-by-side check with last year's declarations page, which is the one- or two-page summary at the front of your policy that lists your limits, deductibles and premium.

## When should my renewal show up?

Florida law sets a deadline for your insurer. Under Florida Statutes 627.4133, a home insurer has to give you written notice of the renewal premium at least 45 days before the renewal date.

Example: your policy renews June 1, 2027. Count back 45 days and the notice is due by April 17, 2027. Backing up through all of May takes 31 days and lands on May 1, and 14 more days lands on April 17.

That window is enough to shop, but not by much. A new insurer may ask for a wind mitigation report (an inspection that records how your roof and windows resist wind) or a 4-point inspection (a check of the roof, electrical, plumbing and heating and cooling on older homes). Booking them takes time, so don't wait. If your notice is late, or never comes, call your agent and ask for the renewal declarations page before the old term ends.

## What should I put side by side?

Use one column for last year and one for the renewal. Copy these lines from each declarations page.

| Line on the page | What it pays for | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Coverage A, Dwelling | Rebuilding the house itself | Did it rise? Is it close to what a rebuild would cost today? |
| Coverage B, Other Structures | Fences, sheds, a detached garage | Usually a set share of Coverage A, so it moves when A moves |
| Coverage C, Personal Property | Your furniture, clothes and other belongings | Paid at replacement cost (new for old) or actual cash value (minus wear)? |
| Coverage D, Loss of Use | Hotel and extra living costs while the home is repaired | Same limit as last year? |
| Coverage E, Personal Liability | Lawsuits if you hurt someone or damage their property | Same limit? |
| Coverage F, Medical Payments | Small medical bills for guests hurt at your home | Same limit? |
| Hurricane deductible | What you pay first on a hurricane claim | The percentage and the dollar amount |
| All other perils deductible | What you pay first on fire, theft, burst pipe and similar claims | Did it change? |
| Roof terms | How roof damage gets paid | Full replacement cost, or a payment schedule that shrinks as the roof ages? |
| Endorsements | Add-ons and limits that change the base policy | Any new cap on water damage, screen enclosures or mold? |
| Discounts and surcharges | Credits and extra charges | Is every discount from last year still there? |

The Florida Department of Financial Services sample declarations page in its homeowners toolkit lists Coverages A through F in this same order, so your page should look familiar. If a line is missing on the renewal, ask why before you pay.

## How do I turn deductibles into real dollars?

Percentage deductibles are where big renewal changes slip past people. A hurricane deductible of 2% means 2% of your Coverage A, not 2% of the damage. So when Coverage A goes up, your hurricane deductible goes up with it, even though the percentage stayed the same.

Example: last year your Coverage A was $350,000. Your policy has an inflation guard, which raises the dwelling limit a little each year, and the renewal shows $364,000 (a 4% increase).

- Last year's 2% hurricane deductible: $350,000 x 0.02 = $7,000
- This year's 2% hurricane deductible: $364,000 x 0.02 = $7,280

Same 2%, and you'd pay $280 more before a hurricane claim pays.

Now say a new quote comes in lower, but with a 5% hurricane deductible on the same $364,000 home.

- 5% deductible: $364,000 x 0.05 = $18,200
- 2% deductible: $7,280
- Difference: $18,200 minus $7,280 = $10,920

Whatever that quote saves you each year, hold it up against $10,920 out of your pocket in a hurricane year. The deductible also runs on a calendar-year clock, which the [Florida hurricane deductible](https://insuranceoutreach.com/hurricane/hurricane-deductible-florida/) page walks through with the state's own example.

## What else might have changed quietly?

Some of the biggest changes hide outside the limits and deductibles.

**A discount fell off.** A wind mitigation report is good for up to five years if nothing major changed on the house. Inspections starting April 1, 2026 use a revised form. If your report aged out, the credit may have dropped, and a new [wind mitigation inspection](https://insuranceoutreach.com/hurricane/wind-mitigation-inspection/) can bring it back if the house still qualifies.

**Your belongings switched to actual cash value.** That means a 10-year-old couch gets paid at what a 10-year-old couch is worth. The same item paid at replacement cost would be replaced new.

**Coverage A drifted away from the real rebuild cost.** Citizens tells its own policyholders that the rebuild figure is adjusted each year for construction and material costs, and that it should be updated after renovations or additions. A limit below the rebuild cost leaves you short after a total loss, and one far above it buys coverage you could never collect. Getting a rebuild estimate is covered in [how much dwelling coverage you need](https://insuranceoutreach.com/home-insurance/how-much-dwelling-coverage-do-i-need/).

**A new endorsement capped something.** Read every insert that came with the renewal. A page labeled as a change in coverage or policy terms is the one that matters most.

## How do I get quotes I can compare fairly?

Hand an agent your renewal declarations page and ask for quotes built on the same Coverage A, the same hurricane deductible, the same all other perils deductible and the same roof terms. Then ask for one more version with whatever you'd consider changing, such as a higher deductible.

Bring what an underwriter will ask for anyway:

- Your current wind mitigation report and the year your roof was installed
- A 4-point inspection if your home is older and the insurer requires one
- Your claims history for the past several years
- Your mortgage company's name and loan number, if you have a mortgage

For a rough sense of the market in your county, the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation runs a free CHOICES tool with sample average rates for model homes. OIR says those figures are for illustration only, so use them as a rough check and get real quotes for your home.

If every private quote comes back more than 20% above what Citizens would charge for comparable coverage, you may be able to get a policy from [Citizens Property Insurance](https://insuranceoutreach.com/renewal/citizens-property-insurance-explained/), the state-created insurer of last resort.

## Is the higher price a rate change or a coverage change?

Split the increase into pieces. Citizens notes that premiums can shift because of general rate changes or because coverage changed. If Coverage A went up 4% and your premium went up about 4%, the bigger limit likely explains most of it. If coverage barely moved and the premium jumped, ask your agent whether the insurer filed new rates, whether a discount dropped, or whether your roof crossed into an older age bracket. Each of those causes, and where it shows on the page, is laid out in [why your home insurance went up](https://insuranceoutreach.com/renewal/why-did-my-home-insurance-go-up/).

## What to do next

1. Put last year's declarations page and the renewal side by side and fill in the table above.
2. Turn both deductibles into dollars, using the new Coverage A.
3. Send the renewal page, your wind mitigation report and your roof year to an agent at least 30 days before the renewal date and ask for matched quotes.
4. Book a new wind mitigation inspection if your report is near five years old or you've made changes like new windows or a new roof.
5. If you switch, start the new policy on the renewal date so there's no gap. You can also leave before renewal, and the steps for [switching home insurance mid-policy](https://insuranceoutreach.com/renewal/switch-home-insurance-mid-policy/) show how to time it.

## Common questions

### How early will I get my home insurance renewal in Florida?

Florida Statutes 627.4133 says the insurer must give you written notice of the renewal premium at least 45 days before the policy renews. Some insurers send it sooner.

### Should I take the cheapest quote I get at renewal?

Only after the coverage matches. Check that Coverage A, the hurricane deductible, the roof payment terms and any water damage limits are the same, then compare price.

### Why is my dwelling coverage higher on the renewal?

Many policies include an inflation guard endorsement, which raises the dwelling limit a little each year to keep up with building costs. The Florida Department of Financial Services says you should still check that the limit fits what it would cost to rebuild.

### Can I change my hurricane deductible at renewal?

Yes, and renewal is the easiest time to do it. Florida insurers must offer $500, 2%, 5% and 10% options, though the $500 option isn't required on homes insured for $250,000 or more.

## Sources

- [Florida Statutes 627.4133, Notice of cancellation, nonrenewal, or renewal premium (2026)](https://www.flsenate.gov/Laws/Statutes/2026/627.4133), The Florida Senate
- [Homeowners' Insurance: A Toolkit for Consumers](https://myfloridacfo.com/docs/consumer-services-libraries/consumerservices-documents/understanding-coverage/consumer-guides/english---homeowners-insurance-toolkit.pdf), Florida Department of Financial Services
- [Florida's Hurricane Deductible](https://myfloridacfo.com/division/consumers/consumerprotections/floridashurricanedeductible), Florida Department of Financial Services
- [Is Your Policy About to Renew? Schedule a Policy Review](https://www.citizensfla.com/-/is-your-policy-about-to-renew-schedule-a-policy-review.), Citizens Property Insurance Corporation
- [CHOICES Rate Comparison Tool](https://floir.gov/consumers/choices-rate-comparison-search), Florida Office of Insurance Regulation

Get a free Florida insurance plan: https://insuranceoutreach.com/
