Insurance Outreach

Home / Life insurance

Term or whole life insurance: which one should you buy?

The short answerIf you are protecting income, children or a mortgage, term life is usually the better buy. It covers a set number of years, often 10 to 30, and costs less for the same payout. Whole life fits a need that never ends, like final costs or money for an heir, because it lasts your whole life and builds cash value, at a higher premium.

Updated . Reviewed by the Insurance Outreach team.

Quick takeaways

  • Term pays only if you die during the years you chose. Whole life pays whenever you die, as long as premiums are paid.
  • Term usually buys the most coverage per premium dollar.
  • Whole life builds cash value you can borrow against or take if you cancel.
  • Pick a term length by writing down the year each need ends.
  • Florida gives you at least 14 days after delivery to cancel a new policy for a full refund.

Term life pays only if you die during the years you picked. Whole life pays whenever you die, as long as the premiums keep getting paid. Most of the other differences come from that.

So the first thing to work out is how long your family's need will last. A 25-year mortgage ends on a known date, while support for a child with a lifelong disability may never end.

What is the difference between term and whole life?

Term life covers you for a set stretch of time. The Florida Department of Financial Services lists the usual lengths as 10, 15, 20 or 30 years, with a level death benefit (the amount your beneficiary receives) and no cash value. If you're alive when the term ends, the coverage stops and nobody gets paid.

Whole life is a type of permanent coverage. Florida's description is coverage to age 100 with level premiums and a guaranteed interest rate on the cash value. Cash value is a savings account inside the policy. You can borrow against it while you're alive, or take it if you cancel.

Part of every whole life premium goes into that savings piece. The Minnesota Department of Commerce says that because of the savings element, premiums tend to be higher, and term generally gives you the most protection for your premium dollar.

Term life Whole life
How long it lasts A set number of years Your lifetime (to age 100 in Florida's description)
Premium Lower for the same death benefit Higher, because part of it builds savings
Cash value Usually none Yes, grows over time
When the period ends Coverage stops, or renews at a higher price if the policy allows it No end date while premiums are paid
Best match Debts and income your family would lose Costs that will exist whenever you die

Who should buy term life?

Term fits anyone whose biggest worry has an end date. A family that depends on your paycheck needs it until the kids can support themselves and the house is paid off, and probably not much after that.

The trick is choosing the length. Write down each need and the year it goes away, then cover the longest one you care about.

Example. You're 35. Your kids are 2 and 5, and you have 29 years left on your mortgage.

  1. Your youngest turns 22 in 20 years (22 minus 2). That's the end of the "raise the kids" need.
  2. The mortgage ends in 29 years. A 30-year term covers it.
  3. One choice is a single 30-year policy large enough for both needs.
  4. Another is a ladder: a 20-year policy for the kid years plus a smaller 30-year policy sized to the mortgage. When the 20-year policy ends, you're left paying for one policy, matched to the debt that's still there.

Two features are worth asking about on any term quote. A renewable policy can continue past its end date without a new health review, though the NAIC warns the renewal premium may be higher than the original. A convertible policy lets you change it into permanent coverage without proving you're still insurable. Get the conversion deadline in writing.

Who is whole life a good fit for?

Whole life makes sense when the money has to be there no matter when you die. Common cases:

  • Funeral and final bills, which every family faces sooner or later. Our guide to final expense insurance covers the small policies sold for this.
  • A dependent who will need support for life, such as an adult child with a disability.
  • Money you want to leave to someone regardless of your age at death.

You also have to be able to keep paying for a long time. Florida's grace period law gives you at least 30 days to pay a late premium on a life policy before it can lapse. After that, a policy with cash value usually gives you choices to keep some coverage or take the cash, which a lapsed term policy can't do.

Whole life has cousins. Universal life lets you change your premium, as long as you pay enough to keep the policy in force, according to the NAIC buyer's guide. Variable life invests the cash value, and the NAIC says it has the greatest potential to grow and the greatest risk of losing value. Ask which one you're being shown.

What happens to the cash value if I cancel whole life?

You get the cash surrender value, which is the cash value minus any surrender charges and unpaid loans. On many policies that value starts low and builds later, the NAIC notes, so canceling in the early years can hand back less than you paid in.

Taxes can apply. The IRS says that if you surrender a policy for cash, you report as income any amount above your cost, which is usually the premiums you paid minus refunds, dividends and unpaid loans that weren't taxed.

Example. Over 15 years you paid $30,000 in premiums. You took no dividends or loans. You surrender the policy for $34,000. Your taxable amount is $34,000 minus $30,000, which is $4,000. The insurer sends a Form 1099-R showing it.

The death benefit itself is treated differently. Money your beneficiary receives because you died generally isn't taxable income, per the IRS. Interest added to it is.

Is "buy term and invest the difference" a good plan?

It can be, if you really do invest the difference every month for decades. The plan works because term costs less, and the gap goes into a retirement account you control. It fails when the difference gets spent.

Whole life does that saving for you, with guarantees, at the cost of slower early growth and less flexibility. That forced habit is worth a lot to someone who knows they won't invest on their own. A disciplined investor gets more control from term plus steady investing, and carries more of the market risk.

Not sure how big the policy should be first? Start with how much life insurance you need, then pick the type.

What to do next

  1. List each person or debt you're protecting and the year that need ends. That list tells you the term length, or whether you need permanent coverage at all.
  2. Check what you already have at work. Our guide on whether work life insurance is enough shows how to find the gap.
  3. Ask for term quotes at two lengths, and ask whether each is renewable and convertible.
  4. If you're looking at whole or universal life, ask for an illustration that splits guaranteed values from projected ones. If your health makes an exam hard, read about life insurance without a medical exam.
  5. Keep your old policy until the new one is in force, and use Florida's free look period (at least 14 days after delivery) to read the new contract before you settle in.

Common questions

Can I switch from term to whole life later?

Only if your term policy is convertible. A conversion option lets you change it to permanent coverage without new health questions, but it has a deadline, so ask for the exact date in writing before you buy.

What happens when my term life policy ends?

Coverage stops and nothing is paid. Some policies let you renew without a new health review, but the renewal premium is usually higher than what you paid before.

Is whole life insurance a good investment?

Whole life is insurance first. Its cash value grows slowly in the early years on many policies, so it works best for people who need lifelong coverage and plan to keep paying for decades.

Is the payout from either type taxed?

The IRS says life insurance paid to a beneficiary because of the insured person's death generally isn't taxable income. Interest paid on top of the death benefit is taxable.

Sources

  1. Life Insurance Overview, Florida Department of Financial Services
  2. What Type of Life Insurance Is Right for You?, National Association of Insurance Commissioners
  3. Life Insurance Buyer's Guide, National Association of Insurance Commissioners
  4. Term vs Permanent Life Insurance, Minnesota Department of Commerce
  5. Publication 525, Taxable and Nontaxable Income, IRS
  6. Life insurance and disability insurance proceeds, IRS