Insurance Outreach

Home / Health insurance

Bronze, silver or gold: which health plan level is right?

The short answerThe metal level tells you how a plan splits costs on average. Bronze pays about 60%, silver about 70%, gold about 80% and platinum about 90%. Lower metals cost less each month and more when you get care. If your income qualifies for extra savings, a silver plan can pay up to 94%.

Updated . Reviewed by the Insurance Outreach team.

Quick takeaways

  • Metal levels show how costs are split. They say nothing about the quality of care.
  • Silver is the only level with extra savings on deductibles and copays.
  • For 2027, no plan can make you pay more than $12,000 a year in covered in-network costs, or $24,000 for a family.
  • Every bronze plan works with a health savings account.
  • Compare the yearly total, premiums plus likely care costs, before you pick.

A common mistake on HealthCare.gov is sorting by premium and clicking the cheapest plan. Another is assuming gold means better doctors. Neither holds up. HealthCare.gov says the metal categories "have nothing to do with the quality of care you get in a plan." They only describe how you and the plan split the bill.

What do bronze, silver, gold and platinum actually mean?

Each level is an average split of covered costs between the plan and you. These figures are from HealthCare.gov.

Level Plan pays, on average You pay, on average Deductible (what you pay before the plan starts paying)
Bronze About 60% About 40% Generally high
Silver About 70% About 30% Generally moderate
Silver with extra savings 73% to 94% 6% to 27% Generally low
Gold About 80% About 20% Generally low
Platinum About 90% About 10% Generally low

"On average" matters. The split is figured across a typical group of members over a year. If you see the doctor twice all year, you may pay far more than 40% of those bills on a bronze plan, because they fall under the deductible. If you have surgery, your share of the year's bills can end up far smaller.

What's the most I could pay in a bad year?

Every Marketplace plan has an out-of-pocket maximum (the cap on what you pay for covered, in-network care in a year, not counting premiums). Once you hit it, the plan pays 100% of covered in-network care for the rest of the year.

Plan year One person Family
2026 $10,600 $21,200
2027 $12,000 $24,000

Those are the legal ceilings. A plan can set its own cap lower, so look for the number on each plan's summary.

So your worst-case year is 12 months of premium plus the plan's out-of-pocket maximum. Add that up for each plan you're weighing.

How do I tell if gold is worth the higher premium?

Compare what the extra premium buys you.

Example. You're weighing a bronze plan and a gold plan, and after your tax credit the gold plan costs $100 a month more. That's $100 x 12 = $1,200 a year extra.

On average, gold pays about 80% of covered costs and bronze about 60%. That's a 20-point difference.

$1,200 / 0.20 = $6,000.

So as a rough rule, gold starts to win if you expect more than about $6,000 in covered medical bills in a year. Below that, bronze usually costs less overall. Run the same math with your own premium gap: yearly premium difference divided by 0.20.

This is a shortcut, since real plans don't pay a flat percentage. Use it to narrow the field. Then check the deductible, the out-of-pocket maximum and the copays for the care you know you'll use, like a monthly prescription or a specialist you see every quarter.

When is silver the smart pick?

When your income qualifies for cost-sharing reductions (extra savings that lower your deductible, copays and coinsurance). HealthCare.gov says you only get them on a silver plan, and they can lift what the plan pays from about 70% to as much as 94%.

KFF describes the income line for that help as 250% of the poverty level. For 2027 coverage, that's $39,900 for one person ($15,960 x 2.5) and $82,500 for a family of four ($33,000 x 2.5).

HealthCare.gov gives its own example. If a silver plan has a $750 deductible, cost-sharing reductions could bring it to $300 or $500, depending on income.

If you qualify and pick bronze anyway, you may save on the premium, but you give up the lower silver deductible that was yours for the asking.

Who should look at bronze?

Bronze fits people who rarely see a doctor and want the lowest monthly bill, and people who want a health savings account (HSA, a tax-free account for medical costs). HealthCare.gov says every bronze and catastrophic plan works with an HSA.

That HSA link has a second benefit. KFF notes that HSA contributions lower the income figure used for your tax credit, which can raise your credit. Our premium tax credit guide shows where the income lines fall.

The catch is the deductible. Before you pick bronze, ask yourself whether you could pay that full deductible in a month if you had to.

What about catastrophic plans?

Catastrophic plans are a fifth category, where available. HealthCare.gov limits them to people under 30 and people who qualify for a hardship or affordability exemption. They have very high deductibles and are meant mainly for worst-case protection. KFF notes the premium tax credit can't be used on them, so if you get a credit, a bronze plan can end up cheaper.

What to do next

  1. Write down the care you expect next year: prescriptions, specialists, any planned surgery or pregnancy.
  2. On HealthCare.gov, check whether you qualify for extra savings. If you do, start with silver.
  3. For your top two or three plans, figure 12 months of premium plus the out-of-pocket maximum, and compare.
  4. Confirm your doctors and drugs are covered before you enroll. Our Florida Marketplace guide has the full sign-up steps, and the open enrollment dates guide has the deadlines.

Common questions

Is a gold plan better than a bronze plan?

Not in quality. HealthCare.gov says the categories have nothing to do with the quality of care. Gold pays more of each bill and costs more each month, so it pays off when you use a lot of care.

Why do people say to pick silver?

Because silver is the only level with cost-sharing reductions, extra savings that lower your deductible and copays. If your income qualifies, a silver plan can cover 73% to 94% of costs instead of about 70%.

Can I use my tax credit on a bronze or gold plan?

Yes. The premium tax credit works on bronze, silver, gold and platinum plans. It can't be used on a catastrophic plan.

What is the most I can pay in a year on a Marketplace plan?

For 2027 plans, the out-of-pocket maximum is $12,000 for one person and $24,000 for a family, for covered in-network care. Premiums don't count toward it.