Quick takeaways
- A $3,600 yearly premium adds $300 to each monthly payment.
- At closing you usually prepay the first year and put a starting balance in escrow.
- The servicer can hold a cushion of no more than one-sixth of a year's escrow bills.
- A big renewal increase can raise your payment twice, once for the new premium and once to fill the shortage.
- If the servicer can't confirm you have coverage, it can buy costly force-placed insurance and bill you.
$3,600 a year is $300 a month. That one line of division is most of what escrow does with your homeowners insurance. The rest is timing, and the timing is where buyers get surprised, usually a year after closing when the first renewal hits.
All the examples below use a made-up $3,600 yearly premium so the math stays easy. Your quote will be different.
What is escrow?
Escrow, sometimes called an impound account, is an account your lender sets up to pay big property bills for you. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) explains that part of each mortgage payment goes into it, and your servicer uses it to pay your homeowners insurance and property taxes. The servicer is the company that collects your payments. It may or may not be the lender you closed with.
Fannie Mae's rules say first mortgages generally must include escrow, though lenders can waive it for an individual loan. Some loans and some laws require it. If you'd rather pay the insurer yourself, ask before closing. Some lenders charge an escrow waiver fee, and it will show on your Closing Disclosure, the final form listing your loan costs.
What do you pay for insurance on closing day?
Insurance shows up twice on your Closing Disclosure.
Section F, Prepaids. This is the premium itself. The CFPB says it's common to pay your first year's homeowners premium in advance at closing. With a $3,600 premium, that's $3,600 paid to the insurer, and your first policy year is covered.
Section G, Initial Escrow Payment at Closing. This money doesn't go to the insurer yet. It gives your escrow account a starting balance so there's enough on hand when the next bill comes due, plus a cushion.
The cushion has a federal limit. Under the CFPB's Regulation X, the extra a servicer holds can't be more than one-sixth of the total yearly bills paid from the account.
Example. Insurance is the only bill in this escrow account, at $3,600 a year.
- One-sixth of $3,600 is $600.
- So the servicer can hold up to $600 as a cushion, about two months of insurance deposits.
- Real accounts also hold property taxes, which raises the yearly total and the cushion with it.
How many months go into Section G depends on your closing date, your first payment date and when the policy renews. Ask your loan officer to walk you through that line on your Loan Estimate.
How does the premium get paid each month?
Once you start making payments, one-twelfth of the yearly premium goes into escrow every month.
Example. A buyer's monthly payment, with made-up numbers for every line:
| Part of the payment | Monthly amount | Where it goes |
|---|---|---|
| Principal and interest | $2,000 | The loan |
| Property taxes ($4,800 a year) | $400 | Escrow, then the county |
| Homeowners insurance ($3,600 a year) | $300 | Escrow, then the insurer |
| Total payment | $2,700 |
Check the math: $4,800 divided by 12 is $400. $3,600 divided by 12 is $300. $2,000 plus $400 plus $300 is $2,700.
When the policy renews, the servicer pays the insurer from the account. Federal rules require servicers to pay escrow bills on time, meaning on or before the deadline to avoid a penalty, as long as your mortgage payment isn't more than 30 days overdue.
Why did your payment go up after the first year?
Once a year the servicer runs an escrow analysis. It compares what came in with what went out and sets next year's monthly amount. You get a yearly escrow statement within 30 days after the account's year ends.
If your insurance went up, the payment usually rises in two pieces. One piece covers the higher premium going forward. The other repays the shortage, the money the account was missing because it collected at last year's lower rate.
Example. The $3,600 policy renews at $4,200.
- New monthly insurance deposit: $4,200 divided by 12 is $350. That's $50 more than before.
- The account collected $300 a month, but the bill was $600 higher than planned. That's a shortage of about $600.
- $600 is more than one month's escrow payment. In that case, Regulation X lets the servicer either leave the shortage alone or spread it over at least 12 months. Spread over 12 months, $600 is $50 a month.
- Payment change for the next year: $50 for the new premium plus $50 for the shortage, so $100 more a month.
- After the shortage is repaid, the extra drops to $50, assuming nothing else changes.
The servicer's real numbers will differ a bit. Taxes change, and the cushion grows with a bigger bill. One-sixth of $4,200 is $700, compared with $600 before. Ask whether you can pay the shortage in one check if you'd rather keep the monthly payment lower.
It works the other way too. If the account ends up with $50 or more extra, the servicer has to refund it within 30 days of the analysis. A rate cut at renewal can put money back in your pocket.
Want to know why the premium rose in the first place? Read why your home insurance went up, and use the renewal comparison guide before you accept it.
Can you switch insurance companies if you have escrow?
Yes. Escrow pays whichever policy your servicer has on record. The danger is the servicer not knowing about the change.
When you switch, give the new company your servicer's mortgagee clause, the exact name and address the policy should list for the lender. Then send the servicer your new declarations page, the summary page of the policy. Our page on switching home insurance before your policy ends covers refunds and timing.
If the servicer can't confirm you have coverage, it can buy force-placed insurance and bill you for it. The CFPB says that coverage can cost twice as much as regular insurance and usually protects only the lender's interest. Federal law requires the servicer to notify you at least 45 days before it charges you. If you get that letter, answer it with proof of your policy right away.
What to do next
- On your Loan Estimate, find the insurance lines in Sections F and G and ask your loan officer to explain each number.
- Keep a copy of your declarations page where you can find it, and send it to your servicer every time the policy changes.
- Read your yearly escrow statement the week it arrives, and compare the insurance figure with your renewal notice.
- Before your first renewal, shop the policy so a big increase doesn't show up first as a higher mortgage payment.
- Before you buy, see how the premium affects what you can borrow.
Common questions
Is homeowners insurance included in my mortgage payment?
It is if you have an escrow account. Part of each payment goes into the account, and the servicer pays the insurer when the policy renews. Without escrow, you pay the insurer directly.
Can I pay my homeowners insurance myself instead of through escrow?
Sometimes. Lenders may waive escrow on some loans, but some charge an escrow waiver fee, and some loans and laws require escrow. Ask your lender before closing, since the fee shows on your Closing Disclosure.
Why did my mortgage payment go up when my rate is fixed?
Your principal and interest stay the same on a fixed-rate loan, but the escrow part follows your insurance and tax bills. If your premium or taxes went up, your servicer raises the monthly escrow amount to match.
What happens to my escrow if I switch insurance companies?
Send your servicer the new declarations page right away so it pays the new company at renewal. The old company owes a refund for unused months, and you should confirm with your servicer where that refund goes.
Sources
- What is an escrow or impound account?, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
- 12 CFR 1024.17, Escrow accounts (Regulation X), Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
- Closing disclosure explainer, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
- Consumer advisory: Take action when home insurance is cancelled or costs surge, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
- B2-1.5-04, Escrow Accounts, Fannie Mae Selling Guide